Quantify

Caterpillar, Inc. vs Plug Power, Inc. — Stock Comparison

Caterpillar, Inc. (CAT) and Plug Power, Inc. (PLUG) are both listed on US exchanges. This page compares their Q·Score ratings, key fundamentals (P/E, margins, growth), and Wall Street analyst consensus side by side. Data sourced from Yahoo Finance and updated on each page load.

vs
Q·Score Winner
Caterpillar, Inc.
CAT6.8/10vs 4.4/10

Caterpillar, Inc. clearly outscores Plug Power, Inc. on Q·Score (6.8 vs 4.4 out of 10), led by Quality (8.2 vs 0.2) and Growth (9.1 vs 6.6). Plug Power, Inc. scores higher on Health, reflecting stronger balance sheet strength. Analyst consensus targets imply greater upside for PLUG (+26.9%) than for CAT (-4.1%).

Price Performance

Normalised to 100 at period start — shows relative performance.

Loading…
● CAT● PLUG

Q·Score Breakdown

6.8
Neutral
Overall
4.4
Bearish
8.2
Quality
0.2
5
Health
6.9
9.1
Growth
6.6
4.9
Valuation
5.3
6.3
Sentiment
4.2
CAT

Earnings growing 30% year-over-year on 22% revenue growth.

⚠ valuation metrics above sector average.

PLUG

Healthy balance sheet and financial position.

⚠ currently unprofitable (-227% margin).

Analyst Consensus

Neutral
-4.1%
Target $945.64
26 analysts
Neutral
+26.9%
Target $3.62
16 analysts

Fundamentals

CAT
PLUG
49.0×
Trailing P/E
—
32.8×
Forward P/E
-17.3×
13.33%
Profit Margin
-227.13%
28.60%
Gross Margin
-31.24%
51.33%
ROE
-128.79%
22.20%
Revenue Growth
22.30%
30.20%
Earnings Growth
—
1.60
Beta
2.12
0.66%
Dividend Yield
—
$454.1B
Market Cap
$4.0B
52-Week Range
CAT
$35899% of range$994
PLUG
$151% of range$5

Frequently Asked Questions

CAT vs PLUG: which stock scores better overall?

Based on Q·Score, Caterpillar, Inc. (CAT) scores 6.8/10 versus Plug Power, Inc. (PLUG) at 4.4/10. The Q·Score measures five dimensions: Quality, Health, Growth, Valuation, and Sentiment. For informational purposes only — not financial advice.

Which has better revenue growth: CAT or PLUG?

Caterpillar, Inc. (CAT) scores higher on Growth (9.1/10 vs 6.6/10). Caterpillar, Inc. reports revenue growth (22.2% YoY) while Plug Power, Inc. reports (22.3% YoY). Growth scores reflect revenue and earnings momentum relative to sector peers.

Is CAT or PLUG more attractively valued?

Plug Power, Inc. (PLUG) scores higher on Valuation (5.3/10 vs 4.9/10). Valuation is assessed using P/E ratio, analyst price targets, and 52-week range positioning relative to sector peers.

What do analysts say about CAT vs PLUG?

There are 26 analysts covering CAT with a consensus price target of $945.64, and 16 analysts covering PLUG with a consensus target of $3.62. Analyst consensus ratings are aggregated from Wall Street research and do not constitute investment advice.

Which is more profitable: CAT or PLUG?

Caterpillar, Inc. (CAT) scores higher on Quality (8.2/10 vs 0.2/10). Net profit margin: CAT at 13.3%, PLUG at -227.1%. Quality scores reflect profit margins, return on equity, and free cash flow generation.

Which has stronger financial health: CAT or PLUG?

Plug Power, Inc. (PLUG) scores higher on Financial Health (6.9/10 vs 5/10). Market beta: CAT at 1.60, PLUG at 2.12. Health scores consider beta, debt-to-equity, and current ratio. All investments carry risk — this is not investment advice.

What are the market caps of CAT and PLUG?

Caterpillar, Inc. (CAT) has a market capitalisation of $454.1B, while Plug Power, Inc. (PLUG) has a market cap of $4.0B. Market cap data is sourced from Yahoo Finance and reflects the most recent available figures.

Do CAT or PLUG pay dividends?

CAT pays a dividend yield of 0.66%, while PLUG does not currently pay a dividend. Dividend yields fluctuate with share price and company payout decisions.

Related Comparisons

CAT vs DE

Q·Score is an educational tool and is not financial advice. Data provided by Yahoo Finance. Updated on each page load. How it's calculated →

Data provided by Yahoo Finance ·  Updated on each page load ·  For informational purposes only · Not financial advice · Quantify.biz © 2026